Skip Navigation
  • Careers
  • Report a Claim
  • Contact Us
Risk Strategies Logo
  • Industries

    • Agriculture
    • Architects & Engineers
    • Aviation
    • Cannabis
    • Construction
    • Dental
    • Education
    • Entertainment
    • Financial Services
    • Fine Art
    • Healthcare
    • Law Firms
    • Marine & Yacht
    • Nonprofit & Human Services
    • Private Equity
    • Public Sector
    • Real Estate
    • Relocation
    • Transportation
    • Waste & Recycling
    • Wineries
  • Solutions

      • Captives
      • Casualty
      • Cyber
      • Environmental
      • International
      • Management Liability
      • Property
      • Surety
      • Employee Benefits Overview
      • Benefit Administration and Technology
      • Benefits Compliance Support
      • Data & Analytics
      • Human Capital Advisory Services
      • International Benefits
      • Absence Management & Ancillary Programs
      • Voluntary & Lifestyle Benefits
      • Medicare
      • Financial & Wealth Overview
      • Life Insurance
      • Private Client Services Overview
      • Homeowners
      • Flood
      • Collections
      • Umbrella & Excess Liability
      • Auto
      • Collector & Exotic Car
      • Boat & Yacht
      • Travel Medical & Trip Insurance
      • Family Office
      • Cyber Insurance - Family Office
      • Cyber Insurance - Individuals
      • Specialty Coverages
      • Private Client Risk Resource Center
    • Reinsurance
      • Risk Management Services Overview
      • Analytics
      • Claims Management & Advocacy
      • Loss Control
      • Safety Consulting Services
      • Pro Safety Training Courses
      • Workers’ Comp: Premium Review & Recovery
  • Consulting

    • Consulting Overview
    • Actuarial Services
    • Healthcare Claim Audit Services
    • Health and Welfare
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Pharmacy Consulting
    • Retirement Benefits
  • News and Insights

    • All Insights
    • Blog
    • Emergency Resource Centers
    • Employee Benefits Compliance Center
    • Events
    • Media Coverage
    • State of the Market Reports
    • Press Releases
    • Private Client Resources
    • Webinars
  • Company

    • About Us
    • Annual Report
    • Careers
    • Culture and Values
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
    • Environmental, Social, & Governance
    • General Terms of Business
    • Leaders
    • Local Expertise
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Recognition & Awards
    • Risk Strategies Foundation
    • Transparency and Disclosures
  • Join Us
    • Careers
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Industries
    • Agriculture
    • Architects & Engineers
    • Aviation
      • Aviation Business Insurance - Manned Risk
      • Non-Owned Aviation
      • Unmanned Aerial System and Drones
    • Cannabis
    • Construction
      • Alternative Solutions
      • Financing & Pre-Construction
      • Insurance Solutions
      • Risk Management
      • Surety
    • Dental
      • Insurance for Dental Professionals
      • Dental Malpractice Insurance
      • BOP Insurance - Dental Practices & DSOs
      • Dental School Graduates
      • Dental Associates & Hygienists
      • Dental Practice Owners
      • Dental Service Organizations (DSOs)
    • Education
      • Employee Benefits for Education
      • Property, Casualty & Liability for Education
      • Student Health & Wellness
        • Student Health Brokerage and Consulting
        • Student Health Plan Administration
        • Student Health Insurance Plans
        • Solutions for Student Athletes
        • Student Health & Wellness Tools
        • Special Risk Insurance
    • Entertainment
      • Film & Television
      • Advertising Production Wrap Ups
      • Advertising/PR
      • Event Cancellation & Non-Appearance
      • Music & Touring
      • Theatrical Production & Live Performance 
      • Venue Insurance
    • Financial Services
      • Asset Managers
      • Banks & Non-Bank Lending
      • Collections
      • Consumer Financial Services
      • Financial Tech
      • Insurance Companies
    • Fine Art
      • Artists
      • Artist Endowed Foundations
      • Auction Houses
      • Fine Art Packers / Shippers / Warehouses
      • Galleries
      • Museums
      • Private Art Dealers / Advisors
      • Private Collectors
    • Healthcare
      • Employee Benefits - Healthcare
      • Managed Care / Stop Loss
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Property & Casualty - Healthcare
      • Reinsurance
    • Law Firms
    • Marine & Yacht
      • Boat & Yacht For Individuals
      • Commercial & Recreational Marine Businesses
        • Marine Businesses
        • Sailing Organizations - Burgee Program
      • Jackline Insurance Solutions for Cruisers
      • Mega Yachts
      • One-Design Insurance Program
      • Crew Medical Insurance
      • Sailors Health Insurance Program
      • US Sailing Insurance Solutions
    • Nonprofit & Human Services
    • Private Equity
      • Crypto Companies
    • Public Sector
      • Public Safety Organizations & Municipalities
    • Real Estate
      • Commercial
      • Community Associations
      • Hospitality
      • Residential / Habitational
      • REITs
      • Retail
      • Specialty Programs
    • Relocation
      • Domestic Household Goods
      • Expat Renters & Living Insurance
      • Relocation Claims Service
      • International Household Goods
      • Supplemental Movers Coverage
      • Temporary Living Insurance
      • Vacant Home
    • Transportation
      • Business Auto Insurance
      • Last Mile Delivery
      • While Under Dispatch Insurance
      • Forwarding & Brokering
      • Workers' Compensation
    • Waste & Recycling
    • Wineries
  • Solutions
    • Commercial Insurance
      • Captives
      • Casualty
        • Analytics
        • Auto Liability & Physical Damage
        • Captives & Alternative Risk Financing
        • Claims Advocacy & Loss Control
        • Excess Liability
        • General Liability
        • Product Recall
        • Workers' Compensation
      • Cyber
        • Cyber Resolute
        • Cyber Risk Assessment and Analytics
        • Cyber Risk Response & Claims Advocacy
        • Cyber Insurance - Family Office
        • Cyber Insurance - Individuals
      • Environmental
        • Contractors Pollution Liability
        • Environmental Excess
        • Environmental Liability Transfer
        • Environmental Liability - Healthcare
        • Environmental Liability - Higher Education
        • Pollution Legal Liability
        • Environmental Liability - Private Equity
        • Professional Environmental Liability Insurance
        • Real Estate Development
        • Remediation Cost Cap
        • Secured Creditor Protection for Lenders
        • Underground Storage Tanks
      • International
      • Management Liability
        • Management Liability - Entertainment
        • Management Liability - Financial Institutions
        • Management Liability - Healthcare
        • Management Liability - Real Estate
      • Property
        • Builder's Risk
        • Property Claims Services
        • Inland Transit and Ocean Cargo
        • Natural Hazard Catastrophe Modeling
        • Political Violence and Terrorism
        • Property Damage & Business Interruptions Valuations
        • Property Loss Prevention and Control
      • Surety
    • Employee Benefits
      • Employee Benefits Overview
      • Benefit Administration and Technology
      • Benefits Compliance Support
      • Data & Analytics
      • Human Capital Advisory Services
      • International Benefits
      • Absence Management & Ancillary Programs
      • Voluntary & Lifestyle Benefits
      • Medicare
    • Financial & Wealth
      • Financial & Wealth Overview
      • Life Insurance
    • Private Client Services
      • Private Client Services Overview
      • Homeowners
      • Flood
      • Collections
      • Umbrella & Excess Liability
      • Auto
      • Collector & Exotic Car
      • Boat & Yacht
      • Travel Medical & Trip Insurance
      • Family Office
      • Cyber Insurance - Family Office
      • Cyber Insurance - Individuals
      • Specialty Coverages
      • Private Client Risk Resource Center
    • Reinsurance
    • Risk Management Services
      • Risk Management Services Overview
      • Analytics
      • Claims Management & Advocacy
      • Loss Control
      • Safety Consulting Services
      • Pro Safety Training Courses
      • Workers’ Comp: Premium Review & Recovery
  • Consulting
    • Consulting Overview
    • Actuarial Services
    • Healthcare Claim Audit Services
    • Health and Welfare
    • Mergers and Acquisitions
    • Pharmacy Consulting
    • Retirement Benefits
  • News and Insights
    • All Insights
    • Blog
    • Emergency Resource Centers
      • Cybersecurity
      • Earthquake
      • Hurricane
      • Pandemic
      • Riot & Civil Unrest
      • Severe Storms
      • Violence & Active Shooter
      • Wildfire
      • Winter Weather
    • Employee Benefits Compliance Center
    • Events
    • Media Coverage
    • State of the Market Reports
    • Press Releases
    • Private Client Resources
    • Webinars
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Annual Report
    • Careers
    • Culture and Values
    • Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
      • BeHEARD Series
      • DE&I Structure
      • Employee Resource Groups
    • Environmental, Social, & Governance
    • General Terms of Business
    • Leaders
    • Local Expertise
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Recognition & Awards
    • Risk Strategies Foundation
    • Transparency and Disclosures
      • General Terms of Business
      • Conflict of Interest Policy
      • Compensation Disclosure
      • Enterprise Risk Management
  • Join Us
    • Careers
      • Benefits & Wellness
      • Investing in Growth & Leadership
      • Life at Risk Strategies
      • Next Steps
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
      • Partnership Benefits
      • Why Join Us?
      • Onboarding & Integration
  • Careers
  • Report a Claim
  • Contact Us

You are about to leave Risk Strategies website and view the content of an external website.

You are leaving risk-strategies.com

By accessing this link, you will be leaving Risk Strategies website and entering a website hosted by another party. Please be advised that you will no longer be subject to, or under the protection of, the privacy and security policies of Risk Strategies website. We encourage you to read and evaluate the privacy and security policies of the site you are entering, which may be different than those of Risk Strategies.

OK
  • News and Insights
  • Blog
Subscribe

Subscribe via Email

  • News and Insights
  • Blog
May 08, 2024

The Baltimore Bridge Collapse: Who’s Liable?

Marine Business
6 min read
By Kevin Kearney, Senior Vice President, Marine and Kristen Teatom, Team Lead, Vice President, Claims
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
The Baltimore Bridge Collapse: Who’s Liable for the Insurance Payout?
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

The collapse of the Francis Scott Key Bridge following a collision with the container ship Dali could result in the most expensive marine insurance payout in modern history, potentially exceeding $1 billion. The ship owners and their insurers, however, may not be liable for the total cost of this devastating accident.

What’s going on?

Six bridge workers tragically died, and the accident has significantly disrupted the Port of Baltimore. The city is suing the cargo ship operators that caused the bridge’s collapse. The FBI has opened a criminal investigation into the deadly incident. Maryland's Attorney General is also seeking legal action to address environmental damage and recover costs.

President Biden launched a federal effort to rebuild the Key Bridge. $60 million in emergency funds were released for initial repairs and design, while Maryland seeks full federal funding through the Baltimore BRIDGE Relief Act.

How the Limitation of Liability Act impacts bridge collapse lawsuits

An important piece of legislation sits at the center of the complex legal battles surrounding the bridge disaster: the Limitation of Liability Act of 1851. Originally intended to support the fledgling American shipping industry and place it on equal footing with the international shipping community, this law caps shipowners’ liability at the vessel’s post-accident value. This means that even though the damages may be vast, the vessel’s insurers might only have to pay a fraction of the total losses.

To limit financial responsibility after a maritime incident, a shipowner files a petition in court to limit its liability to the value of the ship after the accident plus pending freight. Claimants will then try to prove that an act of negligence or condition of unseaworthiness caused the accident. If the claimant does prove this, the burden shifts to the shipowner to prove a lack of privity or knowledge of those acts.

In the infamous case of the Titanic, this maneuver drastically reduced the compensation the survivors and victims' families received.

What does this mean for the Baltimore bridge collapse disaster?

The ship’s owners have already filed a petition for limitation of liability, stating the vessel's value after the incident is $43 million.  The Limitation Action could allow the vessel to limit its liability for personal injury claims and property losses.

The Mayor and City Council of Baltimore filed an answer and the first claim in response to the petition on April 22, 2024, alleging that the vessel was unseaworthy and the shipowners’ actions were negligent, resulting in destruction of its property and associated costs. On April 25, 2024, American Publishing, LLC also filed a class action claim alleging that the negligence of the ship owner caused financial losses to its business and other businesses similarly affected.

Navigating complex insurance claims

Any potential insurance payouts resulting from this disaster hinge on several factors:

  • Damage to the bridge: Rebuilding a structure of this size could easily exceed $100 million. While the federal government has already pledged $60 million, how this interacts with potential insurance claims and the Limitation Action remains unclear. Taxpayers might end up footing a large portion of the bill.
  • General Average: This ancient maritime law dictates that the costs incurred for the benefit of all to achieve a safe arrival at final destination, including salvage operations to clear a wreck, are shared by all stakeholders. This extends financial responsibility beyond the ship and its insurers to include cargo owners and their respective insurers.
  • Liability: Proving the vessel was negligent or unseaworthy is crucial for those seeking damages due to loss of life, injuries, and bridge damage. This will require a thorough investigation into the ship's condition, maintenance records, the Port Captain’s and the crew's actions before the collision.
  • Business Interruption: The Port of Baltimore is a major economic hub, and the extended closure disrupts a vast supply chain. Affected businesses may hold business interruption policies, but insurers are likely to contest payouts. While businesses might try to sue the ship owners to recover their losses, such lawsuits have limited chances of success due to ships' general immunity from liability for pure economic losses.

Lessons from the El Faro ship incident

A more recent example of the Limitation of Liability Act in action is the El Faro case. After the container ship sank near the Bahamas during Hurricane Joaquin in 2015, the owners, TOTE Maritime, also sought to limit their liability.

Despite being found liable for damages, the court allowed the company to limit its total payout. TOTE Maritime reached a settlement with the families of the deceased crew members and survivors, each party receiving $500,000. The National Transportation Safety Board's (NTSB) investigation found the primary cause of the sinking was the captain's poor decision-making but also blamed TOTE Maritime for safety lapses and inadequate oversight.

Risk management

The Key Bridge disaster serves as a stark lesson in the importance of proper risk management. If your business could be vulnerable to similar disruptions, immediate risk mitigation is essential to prevent costly consequences. Here are a few key approaches for proactive strategies to avoid costly disruptions and losses:

  • Make a thorough risk assessment: Identify potential risks across all stages of the shipping process. This includes natural disasters, geopolitical instability, cyberattacks, cargo damage, and theft. Analyze the likelihood and potential impact of each risk to focus mitigation efforts.
  • Plan (and respond): Develop detailed plans for the most impactful risk scenarios. Outline clear communication channels, alternative routes, emergency procedures, and the roles and responsibilities of key personnel. Conduct regular simulations to refine these protocols.
  • Establish robust partnerships: Build strong relationships with reliable carriers, logistics providers, and insurance companies. Transparent communication and contracts that clearly define liability can minimize disputes and protect all parties.
  • Adopt technology: Incorporate technologies like real-time tracking systems, cargo sensors, and predictive analytics. This improves visibility, enables data-driven decision-making, and allows early intervention if problems arise.
  • Foster safety culture: Encourage open reporting of near-misses and potential vulnerabilities to enable proactive solutions.

What the Key Bridge disaster means for tomorrow

While the initial $60 million pledged by the US government to begin the rebuild of the bridge is welcome news, questions remain about how this will interact with existing insurance claims. Due to lawsuits and evidence gathering, determining the true extent of the ship's liability will likely take years.

The Baltimore Bridge disaster brings to light the unique legal complexities and enormous potential financial fallout that haunt the modern shipping industry. While time will tell the lasting ramifications of this disaster, a solid risk management plan can keep you one step ahead of similar incidents.

Want to learn more?

Find Kevin on LinkedIn.

Find Kristen on LinkedIn.

Connect with the Risk Strategies Marine team.

The contents of this article are for general informational purposes only and Risk Strategies Company makes no representation or warranty of any kind, express or implied, regarding the accuracy or completeness of any information contained herein. Any recommendations contained herein are intended to provide insight based on currently available information for consideration and should be vetted against applicable legal and business needs before application to a specific client. 

Related Posts

See all posts

Private Client Marine Business
8 min read
December 02, 2024

How Lithium-Ion Battery Hazards Are Changing Yacht Insurance

Editor's Note: This article originally appeared in SuperYacht Times. Reprinted with permission.
Read article
Risk Strategies Logo
  • Report a Claim
  • Contact
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Consumer Health Data Privacy Notice
  • Accessibility
  • Health Plan Transparency Compliance
  • Accessibility
  • Cookie Policy
  • Health Plan Transparency Disclosure
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
©2025 Risk Strategies. All rights reserved.

Connect with Us

  • LinkedIn
  • X
  • Instagram
  • Facebook